Ruggero Golini, Senior Manager & Julien Melotte, Partner at PwC Luxembourg  Photo: PwC Luxembourg

Ruggero Golini, Senior Manager & Julien Melotte, Partner at PwC Luxembourg  Photo: PwC Luxembourg

Performing double materiality assessment while engaging with stakeholders is the foundation of impactful sustainability reporting.

To produce a trustworthy sustainability report, businesses must understand first how their actions impact the environment, society, and, in turn, their financial performance. This process is known as double materiality because it assesses the importance of sustainability topics from two different angles: external impact and financial implications. It is a requirement for companies under the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD)[1] and a vital component of impactful and comprehensive sustainability reporting.

A double materiality analysis is ultimately about identifying and reporting relevant (that is, material) environmental, social, and governance impacts, risks, and opportunities, and it is carried out in four phases explored in the following sections.

Two perspectives converge in the double materiality assessment process Illustration: PwC Luxembourg

Two perspectives converge in the double materiality assessment process Illustration: PwC Luxembourg

Phase 1: Understanding phase

In the understanding phase, companies establish the foundation for their materiality assessment process, considering the following key points:

·       Own operations and value chain: Materiality is not limited to a company’s operations; it extends to the entire value chain, including upstream and downstream activities. For instance, critical suppliers of raw materials, key customers, and end-users should be included in the analysis.

·       Engagement with stakeholders: Actively involving stakeholders helps in understanding their concerns and how the business impacts people and the environment. This input strengthens the importance of sustainability matters from their perspective.

Phase 2: Assessment phase

The assessment phase focuses on identifying sustainability-related impacts, risks, and opportunities. This can be done through a top-down approach, starting with a list of potential topics, and enhancing it through stakeholder engagement or internal assessments, or a bottom-up approach, where granular impacts are grouped into topics.

For instance, following a bottom-up approach, a company may assess its climate risk via the analysis of different physical risks (such as extreme weather events) and transition risks (such as regulatory changes) to which its operations are exposed.

It is essential to combine research and data analysis with stakeholder engagement to make sure that all relevant impacts, risks, and opportunities are identified and assessed using objective criteria.

Phase 3: Determination phase

In the determination phase, decisions are made about which topics are in the scope of the sustainability report. This includes setting thresholds, aligning with global standards, and outlining the reporting process. Two main processes can be distinguished in this phase:

·       Scoring impacts, risks, and opportunities: impacts are assessed using quantitative and/or qualitative scales based on the severity of actual and potential negative impacts. For risks and opportunities, the effects on performance, financial situation, and cash flows are considered.

·       Determining what to report: All impacts, risks, and opportunities that score higher than a threshold are considered material, and thus, a company must report them. The type of information to disclose around these topics depends on whether it is related to policies, actions, targets, or metrics.

In the final stages of the determination phase, it is important to consider the disclosure requirements for policies and targets, and state explicitly if these are not available. For metrics, they can be omitted if they do not apply to the company context.

Phase 4: Reporting phase

To ensure the double materiality exercise’s effectiveness, it is essential to present it clearly and transparently. This clarity is crucial for the users of the sustainability statement and for auditors. It is necessary to provide detailed explanations of both the process, outlining how the double materiality assessment was conducted, and the outcome, specifying the topics deemed material and the corresponding information included in the sustainability statement.

More information on our website.

To learn more about double materiality, consult the EFRAG (European Financial Reporting Advisory Group) ESRS 2 (European Sustainability Reporting Standards) standard and the guidelines issued by EFRAG in August 2023.

[1] Directive (EU) 2022/2464 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 December 2022 amending Regulation (EU) No 537/2014, Directive 2004/109/EC, Directive 2006/43/EC and Directive 2013/34/EU, as regards corporate sustainability reporting: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:32022L2464