Data is now an integral and unavoidable part of our lives, from the number of steps we make to the number of stocks traded each day. It therefore goes without saying that the data we consume and use as the basis for important decisions must be accurate. This ethos is being echoed by financial regulators throughout Europe who are turning their focus to improved data quality for 2022.
The AMF (Autorité des Marchés Financiers) recently published its supervisory priorities for the financial services industry, highlighting the importance of high quality data and regulatory reporting from investment firms and trading venues. Accurate reporting data is of paramount importance to the oversight of trading activity and the detection of market abuse and manipulation.
MiFID II
It is quite revealing that data quality in the various reporting regimes introduced by MiFID II is one of only two themes flagged by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), that national competent authorities (NCAs) should take into account for 2022.
The other theme relates to costs and fees invoiced by asset managers. The focus on data quality is partly a by-product of asset managers only having to transaction report under MiFID since 2018, whereas the sell-side have been reporting under MiFID I since 2007.
The benefits or being more data-driven
Becoming more data-driven removes the need for regulators to allocate limited resources based on risk where the focus is primarily on larger firms, e.g. through supervisory visits and correspondence, with smaller firms being overseen using event based supervision or thematic reviews.
Clever use of data allows scrutiny of all activity and firms and not just samples.
Preventing market abuse within the asset management sector
The prevention of market abuse within the asset management sector was also one of the AMF’s supervisory priorities for 2021. Regulators are using transaction reports to look out for insider dealing and market manipulation. However, there is a gap in the surveillance net when it comes to Alternative Investment Fund Managers and UCITS management companies that provide MiFID services to third parties. ESMA is proposing that these firms start to transaction report under MiFID following their review last year.
ESMA is also proposing to introduce a MiFID ‘client categorisation flag’. The MiFID client categorisation flag will allow European regulators to assess on a large scale and, in an automated way, whether unsuitable products are being sold to retail clients.
A data-led regulator
Jessica Rusu, FCA’s Chief Data, Information & Intelligence Officer, stated at the FCA’s RegTech forum in February 2022 that a data-driven industry needs a data-led regulator. The FCA is prioritising the use of data science and technology to keep pace with changes in financial services.
Their Data, Technology and Innovation division is building a Digital Unified Intelligence Environment to reassess how FCA collects and analyses data.
Poor data quality can trigger false positives
The Commission de Surveillance du Secteur Financier (CSSF), recently issued a press release on the poor quality of transaction reports it receives under MiFIR. They emphasised that high quality transaction reports are essential to detect market abuse and poor data quality can trigger false positives, which may constitute a serious breach particularly if reporting errors lead to the concealment of market abuse cases. The CSSF recalls Article 47, which determines the sanctions and penalties imposed against investment firms for misreporting under Article 26 of MiFIR.
Essentially, the honeymoon period is over for firms as it is now over four years since MiFID II went live and regulators need better quality data from investment firms and trading venues. It would not be surprising to see enforcement activity in relation to transaction reporting failures, particularly in Europe, where ESMA has been encouraging NCAs to be more proactive with their enforcement power.
Kaizen Reporting can help firms not only detect quality issues in their regulatory reporting, but also help them understand the reporting obligations and corrective measures. For a conversation with Simon or one of our regulatory specialists, please contact us.
This promotional article was written as part of Kaizen Reporting’s membership with the Paperjam + Delano Club. If you wish to become a member of the Club, contact us at [email protected].
