Ten years after the introduction of liquidity risk management requirements for UCITS and nearly eight years for AIFs, liquidity risk still looms large on regulators’ agendas. Their increasing scrutiny has culminated in the following initiatives:
· Two versions of the International Organization of Securities Commissions’ (IOSCO) recommendations on liquidity risk management (2013 and 2018);
· Broader authorization of swing pricing;
· Recommendations on leverage and liquidity risk from the Financial Stability Board (2017) and the European Systemic Risk Board (2017 and 2020); and
· The European Securities and Markets Authority’s (ESMA) guidelines on liquidity stress testing for UCITS and AIFs (2019).
So far in 2021, IOSCO has launched a review of its 2018 guidelines—while ESMA has published the results of its UCITS liquidity risk management survey with 11 areas of attention, warning of liquidity mismatch in some alternative investment funds.
Recent market events will not disprove regulators’ concerns. The early stages of the COVID-19 outbreak induced high volatile market conditions and significant liquidity deterioration in some fixed income and real estate market segments, including money market instruments. Some fund managers were forced to suspend redemptions due to valuation uncertainty, illiquidity of positions within portfolios, or large outflows. Funds suspensions and the collapse of the Woodford fund are two recent examples of how damaging changes in liquidity conditions can be.
But it is not all bad news. Over the past 10 years, the investment fund industry has upgraded its asset and liability liquidity modeling through broader development of internal models or by adopting third-party solutions. Information flows about investor distribution dynamics and asset liquidity risk have been greatly enhanced, and senior management is better informed about the liquidity risks and potential vulnerabilities of the funds they manage.
However, the level of maturity of investment firms still differs across the board. To continue to progress in this area, the industry must tackle several topics, including:
- Identifying and resolving potential liquidity mismatch and high leverage risk
As noted by ESMA, investment funds should continuously monitor their liquidity profile to ensure adequacy between their assets’ liquidity and the liquidity offered to their investors, especially for real estate funds and fund of funds. High leverage can trigger high liquidity risk during quickly deteriorating market conditions and rocketing margin calls, as illustrated by the recent Archegos case.
- Improving data governance and data quality
Assessments of securities’ liquidity risk should be as quantitative as possible to allow for continuous monitoring and to reduce expert judgment and qualitative bias. This requires ongoing access to reliable data such as traded volumes on/off-exchanges, broker quotes, trading sizes, number of brokers and market depth. Bolstered by a strong data quality framework, this can mitigate the risk of inaccurate liquidity presumptions and enable regular quality liquidity assessments.
- Improving liquidity risk governance
Investment firms should implement appropriate early warning indicators for liquidity risk, as well as documented investigative processes with proper escalation for identified issues or deteriorating liquidity conditions.
As liquidity risk is closely interlinked with market, credit, counterparty, valuation and/or operational risks (e.g., failure of settlement systems), an integrated risk management governance can help investment funds take comprehensive mitigation actions.
Investment funds should further adopt liquidity management tools such as swing pricing with frequent swing factor assessments, especially for investment strategies where the asset classes’ volatility can affect liquidity.
- Ongoing liquidity model validation
In addition to data quality, asset and liability liquidity forecasts are susceptible to model risk and hypersensitive to the assumptions and parameters used. They should undergo an initial independent validation and be regularly back-tested. Recent market events offer an ideal opportunity to assess the ability of liquidity models to quickly adapt to evolving liquidity conditions and reflect accurate estimates.
Needless to say, it is easy to assess and monitor the liquidity profile of liquid investments, where abundant and reliable market data is available. More time and effort are required to assess “less liquid” investments and model the joint behavior of investors. The complexity of liquidity risk management—due to limited and/or poor data, non-standardized modeling techniques, and the lack of a one-size-fits-all approach—cannot be tackled by the risk management function alone.
Liquidity touches upon product design, distribution, investments and the overall reputational risk of the investment firm. As a result, the liquidity risk measurement challenge is a fertile ground for interactions that boost value across the investment management value chain, where the risk management function plays a central coordination and review role.
In an environment of evolving measurement techniques and increasing regulatory requirements, investment firms can find great value in continuous training and periodically reviewing their existing frameworks. Judging by the better-informed investment decisions and risk-adjusted performance of large asset managers that have integrated liquidity risk assessment into their overall risk management framework, at Deloitte, we strongly believe that the outcome may be worth the effort.
Should you wish to learn more about our Quantitative Master Classes or our Liquidity risk solutions, please visit our dedicated webpage or get in touch.
